Published under the supervision of Mr Justice Chamberlain, Judge in Charge of the Administrative Court, the Administrative Court Judicial Review Guide 2026 introduces for the first time a dedicated section governing generative artificial intelligence in public law litigation: Paragraph 2.3 (“Using Artificial Intelligence tools”), located within the chapter on Procedural Rigour.
Addressing both legal professionals and litigants in person, Paragraph 2.3 establishes strict procedural expectations for every filing placed before the High Court.
Why Paragraph 2.3 Was Introduced
Following high-profile incidents of fabricated case citations generated by chatbots entering court bundles across England and Wales, the Guide puts court users on formal notice:
- Known Propensity for Error: Large language models and AI chatbots are expressly described as frequently prone to errors and “hallucinations”, including inventing non-existent authorities or misstating statutory propositions.
- Applies Across All Filings: The warning covers claims, grounds for judicial review, skeleton arguments, witness statements, and correspondence prepared with AI assistance.
Duty of Reasonable Care and Verification
Under Paragraph 2.3, relying on an AI output provides zero excuse for inaccurate legal submissions:
- Parties and practitioners must exercise reasonable care to verify independently every authority, legal principle, statutory provision, and factual assertion before filing or relying upon it in court.
- Professional responsibility remains strictly personal to the advocate, solicitor, or party signing or presenting the document.
Sanctions Listed Under Sub-Paragraph 2.3.2
Sub-paragraph 2.3.2 explicitly sets out the severe consequences facing litigants or lawyers who fail to comply:
- Adverse Cost Orders: Wasted costs or punitive indemnity cost orders against the party or legal representative.
- Striking Out: Claims, responses, or offending pleadings may be struck out entirely.
- Regulatory Referrals: Mandatory referral of regulated lawyers to the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) or Bar Standards Board (BSB).
- Contempt and Criminal Escalation: In serious cases involving knowing or reckless fabrication, proceedings for contempt of court or referral to the police.
Practical Compliance Steps for Public Law Practitioners
Litigation teams handling Judicial Review work in 2026 should embed mandatory primary-source citation checks against official judgment databases (BAILII / National Archives / Lexis / Westlaw) before any skeleton argument is settled or filed with the Administrative Court Office.
